Re^3: (Toward a better PerlMonks) Who do we serve, and why, and how can we do it better?

in reply to Re^2: (Toward a better PerlMonks) Who do we serve, and why, and how can we do it better?
in thread (Toward a better PerlMonks) Who do we serve, and why, and how can we do it better?

I sometimes sorely wish that folks could disavow themselves of the notion that “I take XP personally,” because I don’t. (Gasp!)

You protest too much, methinks, insisting, again and again and again, that you don't care about XP and being downvoted, to the point that folks naturally suspect the opposite. For example:

Re: Rewards of Service: "Do I care about the “votes” concerning a post? Nope."
Re^3: Splitting multiple patterns: "I have a Rhett Butler attitude about “XP.”"
Re: "As software grows up" .. what do you do?: "Discussions are welcome; down-votes are merely annoying. Please refrain."
Re: Becoming a Friar on PerlMonks: "I don’t give a tinker’s dam about XP as in “brownie points.”"
Re^3: Fork Results in thousands of processes: "Do you downvote my posts both as yourself and using some sock-puppet account? Just curious."
Re^3: Help with multiple forks: "Responding if I may to BrowserUK’s not-so-Anonymous reply (and his exceedingly discourteous but not-unexpected downvote)"
Re^3: Fork Results in thousands of processes: "And, yeah, I am perfectly aware that you have earned many times more experience-points than have I, so I am not presuming that this discussion is “among equals.”"
Proposal: eliminate down-votes: "a source of personal annoyance (but nothing more) for me ... I have a Rhett Butler approach about such trivialities."
Re: Proposal: eliminate down-votes: "From my point-of-view in the future, these negatives mean nothing to me now ... Go ahead, if you want to ... damn this thread into the oblivion of -1,000 downvotes"
Re: Proposal: eliminate down-votes: "Why is the only response that has so-far been offered here, to this I-think important question, “thirty downvotes?”"
Re^2: Short and easy way to write if...elsif syntax: "To the “down-voters” among you, who may mistake brevity for lack of wisdom or experience, I invite your reconsideration."
Re: Perl 5 Optimizing Compiler, Part 6: A Love Letter To Dave Mitchell, chromatic, and BrowserUK: "Now, if you will please now cast your obligatory down-votes on this reply"
Re: Handle application errors with mod_perl: "Hey ... if that “bothers you,” then with my blessings please down-vote this response to your heart’s content"
Re^4: Threads and signals in Windows (invoking the name): "Your almost-reflexive by-now response to me is to vilify me and to down-vote my comments. It may or may not surprise you that I simply do not care what you do or do not think about a stranger you have never met."
Re: Once again ... is it time to get rid of the Anonymous Monk?: "Ooh, cool ... eight downvotes and counting! OOOOH!! And two more downvotes in less than one minute for this reply! I oughta start collecting these things, and I would if I weren’t laughing so hard ... C’m on, people, lighten up"
Re: My code randomly stops working: "Amazing! A down-vote, not five seconds after this posting was made! Is anyone out there, like, running a “bot” that will do this? Just askin’ ... I find it quite entertaining, really. Pathetic, but laughable"
Re: Additions to the FAQ and a Community Statement: "having from time to time been the subject of “downvoting” and some fairly harsh statements ... I simply take all of these things in-stride ... I welcome it."
Re^3: Remove CGI.pm from Perl Core?: "Will every Monk please keep things 'round here “strictly business” and just skip the jabs and downvotes? They get wearisome."
Re^2: (Toward a better PerlMonks) Who do we serve, and why, and how can we do it better?: "I raise this issue (yet again ...) merely to “counter negative-XP.” Believe it or not, I have a Rhett Butler attitude about that."
Re: Maximum down-votes per monk/day: "No, I mean that quite seriously. (Sorry to disappoint those few of you who actually care about such things.) I made a statement, and I Rhett Butler what you “think about” it, or don’t."
Re^3: Threads and signals in Windows (invoking the name): "And somehow, despite all that, accumulate 12,530 experience points and counting."
Re: Lots of votes with nowhere to go :-): "I’ve got about 13,000 experience-points and they do feel warm and fuzzy, but I have no idea what to use them for."
Re^3: How to deal with the fact that Perl is not releasing memory: "(Instead of blindly down-voting ...) would you please point out my error? Seeing a negative number tells me nothing, although I am quite used to it by now."
Re: Splitting up a filesystem into 'bite sized' chunks: "Maybe I should adopt the principle of writing every single terse-comment that I am prone to in a splendiferous loquacious paragraph, or three, in a vain attempt to forestall the “down-vote demons.”"
Re: Negative voting: "I seem to be quite the downvote-magnet ... I am indifferent to “XP”"
Re^2: Negative voting: "without fear (which BTW I don’t have) of “downvotes”"
Re^2: Negative voting: "The reason why I would quietly harp about this point is, actually, not “a wounded ego.”"
Re^3: Would you suggest alternative names for Perl 6?: "Okay, I’ll take-on this assertion and even (why not?) assert that every one of you who “down-voted” my post did so because you are both clueless and wrong!!” (Cowabunga! Here goes!! Downvote me! I don’t care!! Wheeee!!!)"
Re^3: why appears AnonymousMonk and how to update posts: "I don’t give a damn about “experience points!™”
Re^3: [OT] Python vs R: "Now, may I gently remind you all ... you can go ahead and pile-on a hundred thousand down-votes if that’s how you get your jollies, but ... in this case, I do absolutely know what I am talking about, because I have done this"
Re: hash key: "However, as is my custom, I did not downvote these – or any – posts"
Re: Cached(?) pages when not-logged-in sometimes appear to be very seriously out-of-date: "But when I logged in, my (of course, seriously-downvoted) thread appeared first." "So, is there, say, a “sundialsvc4 filter?” It would not surprise me, of course, since I seem to be someone who can collect fifty down-votes for reporting an apparent problem with a web-site to the people who are supposed to be responsible for maintaining it."
Re: Anonymous Monk comment(s) on questions: "Take it from a long-time participant who on any typical day finds his XP rating much more likely to go backwards than forwards: “Anonymous Monk” has for years been the Holy Refuge of Monks who did not wish to risk Un-Holy Down-Votes as they sought to Vent Their Spleens."
Re: I can upvote a node multiple times! Well... sort of.: "Upvotes ... Downvotes ... “Meh.” Really, the only thing that really matters is the content."
Re: Sort undef: "Although I do not ever “down”-vote, some of these solutions are, IMHO, very clearly bad ones"
Re: Patience is a Monk Virtue: "As for myself, I give away upvotes freely, and never downvote."
Re^2: Match all Non-0 and Letters: "Well, here goes my only up-vote to this entire thread ... (BTW, I do not downvote)"

If you are truly indifferent to downvotes, why repeatedly put forward the suggestion of removing them from this site?

Update: Added extra quotes from Re^3: Threads and signals in Windows (invoking the name), Re: Lots of votes with nowhere to go :-), Re^3: Fork Results in thousands of processes, and Re^3: How to deal with the fact that Perl is not releasing memory and others.

Comment on Re^3: (Toward a better PerlMonks) Who do we serve, and why, and how can we do it better?

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^4: (Toward a better PerlMonks) Who do we serve, and why, and how can we do it better? by Argel (Prior) on Jun 25, 2013 at 21:08 UTC
Right, he cares so much about XP that he posts these types of nodes that he knows will generate lots of downvotes that presumably translate into losing XP. And he is a bit more on the prolific side, so I'm not sure how much I would read into the quantity of posts. Well, I will concede that perhaps he is interested in losing XP.... Elda Taluta; Sarks Sark; Ark Arks My deviantART gallery	[reply]

In Section Perl Monks Discussion