comment on

Another way to look at this is to rank-order monks by XP/writeup and by writeups/month (the latter I used just for a more tractable number in my intermediate calculations). That examines "contribution" in a couple of different ways. Then we can look at who is ranked well in each category. ~~There are~~ I chose two ways of looking at that combination -- minimum combined vector distance (who's closer to rank 1 in both) or a linear average of the two ranks. Using Saints in our Book, here's a look at the top 30 each way:

Top 30 Saints-in-our-Book by Combined Rank (also see a chart of this with a few monks highlighted)

XP Rank	Name	XpW Rank	WpM Rank	Average Rank	Combo Rank
44	brian_d_foy	109	45	77.0	117.9
17	grinder	85	98	91.5	129.7
3	Ovid	131	33	82.0	135.1
161	wfsp	120	114	117.0	165.5
15	Corion	159	63	111.0	171.0
56	valdez	99	143	121.0	173.9
39	rob_au	132	115	123.5	175.1
64	rinceWind	129	131	130.0	183.9
62	kvale	147	119	133.0	189.1
63	liz	179	65	122.0	190.4
5	Zaxo	194	18	106.0	194.8
51	borisz	184	69	126.5	196.5
61	FoxtrotUniform	144	138	141.0	199.4
41	strat	64	193	128.5	203.3
73	vek	134	154	144.0	204.1
40	footpad	79	189	134.0	204.8
30	mirod	187	87	137.0	206.2
95	eyepopslikeamosquito	117	172	144.5	208.0
10	dws	207	34	120.5	209.8
186	saintmike	173	120	146.5	210.5
11	jeffa	208	37	122.5	211.3
25	broquaint	204	62	133.0	213.2
100	tbone1	84	204	144.0	220.6
93	blokhead	148	166	157.0	222.4
203	jbrugger	215	58	136.5	222.7
94	PopcornDave	163	153	158.0	223.6
65	samtregar	202	96	149.0	223.7
32	hsmyers	50	219	134.5	224.6
117	Enlil	154	169	161.5	228.6
54	jmcnamara	192	128	160	230.8

Top 30 Saints-in-our-Book by Average Rank

XP Rank	Name	XpW Rank	WpM Rank	Average Rank	Combo Rank
44	brian_d_foy	109	45	77.0	117.9
3	Ovid	131	33	82.0	135.1
17	grinder	85	98	91.5	129.7
5	Zaxo	194	18	106.0	194.8
15	Corion	159	63	111.0	171.0
161	wfsp	120	114	117.0	165.5
10	dws	207	34	120.5	209.8
56	valdez	99	143	121.0	173.9
63	liz	179	65	122.0	190.4
11	jeffa	208	37	122.5	211.3
39	rob_au	132	115	123.5	175.1
51	borisz	184	69	126.5	196.5
41	strat	64	193	128.5	203.3
64	rinceWind	129	131	130.0	183.9
62	kvale	147	119	133.0	189.1
25	broquaint	204	62	133.0	213.2
40	footpad	79	189	134.0	204.8
32	hsmyers	50	219	134.5	224.6
19	adrianh	244	26	135.0	245.4
203	jbrugger	215	58	136.5	222.7
30	mirod	187	87	137.0	206.2
31	TStanley	52	229	140.5	234.8
27	gmax	37	244	140.5	246.8
61	FoxtrotUniform	144	138	141.0	199.4
21	davido	268	14	141.0	268.4
22	pg	264	22	143.0	264.9
73	vek	134	154	144.0	204.1
100	tbone1	84	204	144.0	220.6
95	eyepopslikeamosquito	117	172	144.5	208.0
186	saintmike	173	120	146.5	210.5

(Some names got compressed to eliminate whitespace in intermediate processing. Apologies.)

-xdg

Code written by xdg and posted on PerlMonks is public domain. It is provided as is with no warranties, express or implied, of any kind. Posted code may not have been tested. Use of posted code is at your own risk.

In reply to Re: Best of the Best Users in Perlmonks site by xdg
in thread Best of the Best Users in Perlmonks site by l.frankline

Are you posting in the right place? Check out Where do I post X? to know for sure.
Posts may use any of the Perl Monks Approved HTML tags. Currently these include the following:
<code> <a> <b> <big> <blockquote> <br /> <dd> <dl> <dt> <em> <font> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <hr /> <i> <li> <nbsp> <ol> <p> <small> <strike> <strong> <sub> <sup> <table> <td> <th> <tr> <tt> <u> <ul>
Snippets of code should be wrapped in <code> tags not <pre> tags. In fact, <pre> tags should generally be avoided. If they must be used, extreme care should be taken to ensure that their contents do not have long lines (<70 chars), in order to prevent horizontal scrolling (and possible janitor intervention).
Want more info? How to link or How to display code and escape characters are good places to start.


Don't ask to ask, just ask
	PerlMonks