I'd avoid AUTOLOAD. I see two realistic alternatives. The first is to not use different methods but one and the same and pass an argument. A possible implementation would be

{
    package MyBase;

    sub is {
        my $self = shift;
        my ($type) = @_;

        my $method = 'is_' . $type;

        if (my $code = $self->can($method)) {
            return $self->$code;
        }

        return 0;
    }
}

{
    package Foo;
    use base MyBase::;
    sub is_foo { 1 }
}
{
    package Bar;
    use base MyBase::;
    sub is_bar { 1 }
}
{
    package FooAndBar; # Faker!
    use base MyBase::;
    sub is_foo { 1 }
    sub is_bar { 1 }
}

printf "%-9s %s %s\n", $_, $_->is('foo'), $_->is('bar')
    for Foo::, Bar::, FooAndBar::;

__END__
Foo       1 0
Bar       0 1
FooAndBar 1 1
[download]

package MyBase;
use strict;
use Symbol 'qualify_to_ref';

sub import {
    my $class = shift;
    if (@_) {
        if ($_[0] eq '-base') {
            my (undef, %p) = @_;
            my $type = $p{is}
                or die '...';
            my $pkg = caller;

            _setup_inheritance($class => ($pkg, $type));
        }
        else {
            die '...';
        }
    }
}

sub _setup_inheritance {
    my ($class) = shift;
    my ($pkg, $type) = @_;

    $type !~ /\W/
        or die '...';

    my $method = 'is_' . $type;

    {
        my $gref = qualify_to_ref($method);
        *$gref = sub { 0 } unless defined &$gref;
    }
    {
        my $gref = qualify_to_ref($method => $pkg);
        *$gref = sub { 1 };
    }

    push @{*{qualify_to_ref(ISA => $pkg)}}, $class;

    return;
}

1;
[download]

{
    package Foo;
    use MyBase -base, is => 'foo';
}
{
    package Bar;
    use MyBase -base, is => 'bar';
}

printf "%-9s %s %s\n", $_, $_->is_foo, $_->is_bar
    for Foo::, Bar::;

__END__
Foo       1 0
Bar       0 1
[download]

lodin