The main difference is that cgiapp_init() is called once by new, while cgiapp_prerun() is called everytime a request comes in. In a standard CGI environment, both will always happen, but in a modperl environment, cgiapp_init() will only happen when the server first starts.

The order of operation in a CGI::Application is basically:

1. cgiapp_init()
2. setup()
3. cgiapp_prerun()
4. your selected run mode
5. cgiapp_postrun()
6. teardown()

cgiapp_init() and setup() are called in the class's new() method, while the remaining hooks are run in the class's run() method.

The order of operations you provide does a better job at explaining this than your statement, "cgiapp_init() is called once by new, while cgiapp_prerun() is called everytime a request comes in".

Basically, cgiapp_init() is called as the object is first created in order to setup the environment for the application. cgiapp_prerun() is called prior to executing the selected run mode for a given request. I typically use cgiapp_prerun() to check if the run mode is allowed at this point by this user -- i.e. I use cgiapp_prerun() as the place to implement ACLs.

I know this is an old thread, but I ran into an issue under mod_perl where cgiapp_init was being called on every request, not just at server (or process) start. I did some searches and found this: http://old.nabble.com/cgi%3A%3Aapplication%3A%3Adispatch-and-modperl-td29916199.html Summary: they're both called on every request. Not sure if it's a change since this thread was posted but the information here doesn't seem to be correct.

Summary: they're both called on every request. Not sure if it's a change since this thread was posted but the information here doesn't seem to be correct.

Its neither, its a matter scoping :)

If this is your mod_perl application

sub handler {
   my $app = MyCGIAppSubclass->new;
   $app->run;
}
[download]

cgiapp_init is going to get called with every request, obviously, because you're creating a new object each time -- this is typical Apache::Registry/ModPerl::Registry, running unmodified .cgi's under mod_perl

But if your mod_perl application is

my $app = MyCGIAppSubclass->new;
sub handler {
   $app->run;
}
[download]

Then init/setup is only done once, and only run is done upon every request.

So nothing changed, this are working as designed, as they always have.

See Understanding the application flow of CGI::Application and CGI::Application::Loop

See also the source of CGI::Application::FastCGI

<Reveal this spoiler or all in this thread>

If you want to run CGI::Application as mod_perl handlers as I've shown above with persistent object, you will have to reset query, just like CGI::Application::FastCGI

The theoretical difference is that cgiapp_init() and setup() should do things like set up your configuration vs. cgiapp_prerun() which should handle things like logging the request and setting up your per-request items. And, the same difference applies to cgiapp_postrun() (per-request) and teardown() (per-application).

Thanks dragonchild, that helps. I assume by "persistent" you mean something like mod_perl? I'm running the regular old CGI cycle, so may I can just dispense with the cgiapp_prerun.

Well, on to C::A and cookies...


—Brad
"The important work of moving the world forward does not wait to be done by perfect men." George Eliot

I can just dispense with the cgiapp_prerun.

Don't. You will still benefit mentally from the separation of app-setup vs. response-setup. Plus, if you keep them separate, your migration to mod_perl will be easier when (not if!) it happens.

---

My criteria for good software:

1. Does it work?
2. Can someone else come in, make a change, and be reasonably certain no bugs were introduced?

Cookies? What are cookies?

http://cgiapp.erlbaum.net/cgi-bin/cgi-app/index.cgi?CgiApplicationPluginSessionExample

:0)