Because this has REAL BAD potential, let me start by saying what I do not want:

after typing the title, these were the first things that came to my mind as I thought about what I would think if I saw that title on the Newest Nodes list. Hopefully that will make me a bit more flame retardant : )

What I *am* thinking of is a place for anymonk to get a sanity check from the monastery. I know I am often expected to wear all the hats on some projects, either because there just is no one else to wear them or because they are side jobs I take on real quick for small chunks of cash. It is very easy on these projects, at least for me :), to go down bad paths not because of bad code, but bad ideas and direction. It's always easier to work when you have a sounding board. So perhaps there could be a place for monks to put up details about these projects just to see what other monks would say.

I'm thinking it would be it's own section so that it would appear as another heading on newest nodes that people could ignore if they didn't feel like paying attention. Also so it could be VERY HEAVILY MODERATED :) I'm thinking:

The questions that still float in my head are:

as stated at the start of this, I see that there could be really bad potential for this, but I can think enough times where if I'd simply been forced to type out what I was thinking for someone else to see, or had someone else read through my specifications or goals, I could have been saved a lot of time and effort because that second pair of eyes (or even the potential of them) would have been enough to catch the insanity I was about to embark on. The former happens to me all the time here already. I have something I'm working on, hit a wall, work on it, fail to solve it, come here to post and as I formulate the post see the problem. I'm thinking it would happen with the other more abstract aspects of the projects as well if there were someplace for me to post those where they would not be noise.

This may be total insanity itself. let me know : )

"sometimes when you make a request for the head you don't
want the big, fat body...don't you go snickering."
                                         -- Nathan Torkington UoP2K a.k.a gnat

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
RE: Monk Project Section
by little (Curate) on Nov 11, 2000 at 00:47 UTC
    I like the idea, and just to give my two cents I'd like to appreciate the needs for more structure within all sections, so it's easier to navigate and to find related stuff. Regarding code, I'd suggest to post your idea in the Project section, but post the code in the Code Review section under the referring subsection. which should as I understood also be restricted in access only to higher level monks, even this means I'm putting myself out of the door. :-)
    might have also a look at
    Have a nice day
    All decision is left to your taste