http://qs321.pair.com?node_id=194645


in reply to Are prototypes evil?

Prototypes are one of those things that you shouldn't use, unless you understand why you shouldn't use them. Consider
sub foo ($$) { print join " / ", map "'$_'", @_; } my @x = qw(a b); foo(@x);
This will print '2'. Not 'a' / 'b' as one might expect. Prototypes in Perl aren't. They would probably best be called "context coercion templates". A $ will coerce anything into a scalar. List/hash flattening no longer applies. When using a single ($), it's not too bad, but if you use prototypes for more parameters, you can easily surprise users of that function (including yourself). The only "prototype" I'd seriously consider is &, which lets me pass a bare(!) BLOCK that implicitly becomes a subref to a closure to the function.

Makeshifts last the longest.