apparently, password auth doesn't work in Net::SSH2

Given that there's a method specifically for that and no unsolved reported bugs it would be interesting to know what makes you claim this. Perhaps with an SSCCE?

PS. Note that I'm not advocating password auth over publickey auth here, just that the former should be every bit as possible as the latter with Net::SSH2.

In the thread Net:SSH2 channels after a fair bit of going-around I discovered that the reason that I couldn't get a channel was twofold. First, auth_ok lies and second, the auth_password just didn't work. Another poster in the thread said he had similar problems. I didn't pursue it any further: once I switched to publickey all the problems went away {and I turned to other troubles I had in my code :o)}. I believe this was a windows problem -- several folk confirmed that it worked OK on unix. If I get a chance I'll try it again and post more info if I get it.

BernieC: I was surprised that a basic feature like password authentication wouldn't work. So I tried on a local machine at $work. It worked with the $ssh2->auth_password() for me. After some more looking, I printed out $ssh2->auth_list(), and that gave a clue, which sounded familiar to something I'd read recently. It turned out to have been clarified by what salva (the module's author) already told you in Re^4: Can't get $ssh2->check_hostkey to work: shell02.theworld.com requires keyboard-interactive authentication, but you were using password authentication, which is not the same thing: so you were using the wrong authentication type. The results of my experiment, to make it more explicit:

#!/usr/bin/env perl
use warnings;
use strict;
use Net::SSH2 ':all';
use Config;

my $host = 'REDACTED';
my $username = 'REDACTED';
my $password = 'REDACTED';

print STDERR "__DATA__\n\n__RESULTS__\n";
print STDERR "\$] => $]\n";
print STDERR "$_ => $Config{$_}\n" for qw/archname osname osvers/;

print STDERR "\n\nhost at \$work\n";
my $ssh2 = Net::SSH2->new();
my $rv = $ssh2->connect($host) or $ssh2->die_with_error;              
+                  print STDERR "\tconnect           => $rv\n";
#$rv = $ssh2->check_hostkey(LIBSSH2_HOSTKEY_POLICY_ASK) or $ssh2->die_
+with_error;        print STDERR "\tcheck hostkey    => $rv\n";  # yes
+, I know I should... but not doing this for now; you had trouble, too
+... and I trust this local host
$rv = $ssh2->auth_list($username) or $ssh2->die_with_error;           
+                  print STDERR "\tauth_list         => $rv\n";
$rv = $ssh2->auth_password($username, $password) or $ssh2->die_with_er
+ror;              print STDERR "\tauth_password     => $rv\n";
my $chan = $ssh2->channel() or $ssh2->die_with_error;                 
+                  print STDERR "\tget channel       => $rv\n";
$rv = $chan->exec('ls -l') or $ssh2->die_with_error;                  
+                  print STDERR "\texec ls           => $rv\n";
print STDERR "line read: " . $chan->readline();
$rv = $chan->close() or $ssh2->die_with_error;                        
+                  print STDERR "\tchan close        => $rv\n";
$rv = $ssh2->disconnect() or $ssh2->die_with_error;                   
+                  print STDERR "\tdisconnect           => $rv\n";

print STDERR "\n\nshell02.theworld.com:\n";
$ssh2 = Net::SSH2->new();
$ssh2->connect('shell02.theworld.com') or $ssh2->die_with_error;
$rv = $ssh2->auth_list() or $ssh2->die_with_error;                    
+                 print STDERR "\tauth_list                => $rv\n";
$rv = $ssh2->auth_password_interact($username) or $ssh2->die_with_erro
+r;               print STDERR "\tauth_password_interact   => $rv\n";
    # this wouldn't work on my strawberry perl: "Non-blocking ReadLine
+ is not supported on this architecture"

__DATA__

__RESULTS__
$] => 5.026002
archname => MSWin32-x64-multi-thread
osname => MSWin32
osvers => 10.0.16299.371


host at $work
        connect           => 1
        auth_list         => publickey,gssapi-with-mic,password
        auth_password     => 1
        get channel       => 1
        exec ls           => 1
line read: total 948
        chan close        => 1
        disconnect           => 1


shell02.theworld.com:
        auth_list         => publickey,keyboard-interactive
REDACTED's password? Non-blocking ReadLine is not supported on this ar
+chitecture at C:/usr/local/apps/berrybrew/perls/5.26.2_64_PDL/perl/ve
+ndor/lib/Net/SSH2.pm line 314.
[download]

Notice: my $work host said "publickey,gssapi-with-mic,password" -- ie, it accepts password authentication. But when I checked shell02.theworld.com, it just accepts "publickey,keyboard-interactive". So the valid complaint is "I tried auth_password() even though the host required auth_password_interact(), and it didn't work.".

And, I didn't try very many experiments with auth_password_interact(), but the one I showed above showed that "Non-blocking ReadLine is not supported on this architecture", so it might be a valid complaint to say "My host doesn't accept auth_password(); the host claims to accept auth_password_interact(), but trying that on Strawberry didn't seem to work, and gave the error 'Non-blocking ReadLine is not supported on this architecture'". This would be the response I would give to salva's post in the other thread, to flag salva that there's been a response.

But to claim that "auth_password just didn't work" does not tell the whole, accurate story.

update:: added Re^5: Can't get $ssh2->check_hostkey to work to ask salva about the ReadLine error on strawberry perl

edit 2:: added paragraph breaks to make it more readable

I believe this was a windows problem -- several folk confirmed that it worked OK on unix.

I see. In that case I will be not be in a position to help you solve it. :-)

However, if you can verify that it is a problem with the module (even if only on MSWin32), it would be good to raise that as an issue so that it can be fixed by the maintainers.

auth_password() works fine on Windows (Win10 x64 / Strawberry Perl 5.24.1). See VinsWorldcom's scratchpad.