in reply to RE: Keep the vote XPs. Don't increase vote #.
in thread Scalability of the voting system
I like BBQ's ideas
about limiting votes/rewards for voting out, and his
signal/noise comment pinpointed a nagging idea I've had...
What about awarding XP based on signal/noise? Perhaps if + votes >= # of posts...?
This would certainly encourage quality posts, discourage "noise" and "me too" posts, and give a very real reward to those who go out of the way to produce thoughtful and helpful posts.while ($PositiveVotes >= $NumberOfPosts){ foreach (new Post){ $XP++ if $_->receives('A Positive Vote'); } }
Number of posts is currently a primary measure of a monk's worth, but shouldn't we also reward the less wordy, but more thoughtful monks among us?
This would be even more effective if there were fewer non-posting ways to earn XP, but...
Russ
|
---|
In Section
Perl Monks Discussion