http://qs321.pair.com?node_id=11144039


in reply to getsockopt truncating values to 256 bytes ?

This is a very interesting find. Please do keep us updated, and give a shout out if you want help further troubleshooting it.

On:

steve@maezi ~/scratch >system_profiler SPSoftwareDataType
Software:

    System Software Overview:

      System Version: macOS 12.2.1 (21D62)
      Kernel Version: Darwin 21.3.0

[download]

I experience the same issue:

steve@maezi ~/scratch >perl 256.pl
The TCP_INFO structure seems to be truncated to 256 bytes on this syst
+em.

[download]

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^2: getsockopt truncating values to 256 bytes ?
by Yaribz (Beadle) on May 21, 2022 at 12:03 UTC

    Thanks. I guess what will happen is that the hardcoded limit will just be increased in Perl core code.

    However I wanted to be able to retrieve the full TCP_INFO structure even when using older Perl versions... So regarding my original question "what can I do to retrieve the full TCP_INFO structure ?", here is the workaround I came up with, which seems to be working fine according to first results: 

    use constant {
  DARWIN_SYS_getsockopt => 118, # from bsd/kern/syscalls.master
  GETSOCKOPT_MAXLEN => 512, # enough for now I guess...
};

sub darwin_getsockopt {
  my $optval = "\0" x GETSOCKOPT_MAXLEN;
  my $optlen=pack('i',GETSOCKOPT_MAXLEN);
  my $rv=syscall(DARWIN_SYS_getsockopt,fileno($_[0]),$_[1],$_[2],$optv
+al,$optlen);
  return $rv < 0 ? undef : substr($optval,0,unpack('i',$optlen));
}

    [download]

    Here is a revised version of the test program, using the workaround when run on macOS: 
    use Socket qw'PF_INET SOCK_STREAM IPPROTO_TCP inet_aton sockaddr_in';

use constant {
  DARWIN_TCP_INFO => 0x200, # from bsd/netinet/tcp.h
  DARWIN_SYS_getsockopt => 118, # from bsd/kern/syscalls.master
  GETSOCKOPT_MAXLEN => 512, # enough for now I guess...
};

sub darwin_getsockopt {
  my $optval = "\0" x GETSOCKOPT_MAXLEN;
  my $optlen=pack('i',GETSOCKOPT_MAXLEN);
  my $rv=syscall(DARWIN_SYS_getsockopt,fileno($_[0]),$_[1],$_[2],$optv
+al,$optlen);
  return $rv < 0 ? undef : substr($optval,0,unpack('i',$optlen));
}

my $GETSOCKOPT_FUNC = $^O eq 'darwin' ? \&darwin_getsockopt : \&CORE::
+getsockopt;

my $TCP_INFO = ($^O eq 'darwin' ? DARWIN_TCP_INFO : eval { Socket::TCP
+_INFO() })
    or die "This system doesn't support the TCP_INFO structure.\n";

my ($testHost,$testPort)=('perl.org',443);

socket(my $sock, PF_INET, SOCK_STREAM, IPPROTO_TCP)
    or die "Could not create socket - $!\n";

my $iaddr=inet_aton($testHost);
my $paddr=sockaddr_in($testPort,$iaddr);
connect($sock,$paddr)
    or die "Failed to connect to $testHost:$testPort - $!\n";

my $tcpInfoData=$GETSOCKOPT_FUNC->($sock,IPPROTO_TCP,$TCP_INFO)
    or die "Error while calling getsockopt - $!\n";

my $tcpInfoLength=length($tcpInfoData);
if($tcpInfoLength < 256) {
  print "This system doesn't have a TCP_INFO structure large enough to
+ reproduce the problem.\n";
}elsif($tcpInfoLength == 256) {
  print "The TCP_INFO structure seems to be truncated to 256 bytes on 
+this system.\n";
}else{
  print "This system doesn't seem to be affected by the problem (TCP_I
+NFO length: $tcpInfoLength).\n";
}

    [download]
    And finally, here is another implementation of the workaround, using a more generic approach to let the user specify a buffer length if needed (optional argument), the ideal solution in my opinion (if it was implemented in Perl core to be more efficient): 
    sub getsockopt_darwin_gen {
  return &CORE::getsockopt if(@_ < 4);
  my $optlen = pop;
  my $optval = "\0" x $optlen;
  $optlen=pack('i',$optlen);
  my $rv=syscall(DARWIN_SYS_getsockopt,fileno($_[0]),$_[1],$_[2],$optv
+al,$optlen);
  return $rv < 0 ? undef : substr($optval,0,unpack('i',$optlen));
}

    [download]
[reply]
[d/l]
[select]

In Section Seekers of Perl Wisdom